Salary, Cost of Living & Best Neighborhoods in Brookhaven, NY

Last Updated: January 6, 2026By Tags:
Brookhaven, NY

Brookhaven NY Salary And Cost Of Living Overview

Brookhaven, NY, located in Suffolk County on Long Island, offers a blend of suburban living, coastal access, and proximity to New York City. For professionals, families, and retirees evaluating a move, understanding the salary levels, cost of living, housing market, and local schools in Brookhaven is essential. This guide provides a detailed look at the financial realities of living in Brookhaven, NY, while also highlighting the best neighborhoods and education options. By the end, you will have a clear picture of what it takes to live comfortably in this dynamic Long Island community.

Average Salary In Brookhaven NY

When evaluating a potential relocation or job opportunity, the average salary in Brookhaven, NY is a critical factor. While actual income varies by industry, experience, and education, residents typically earn slightly more than the national average due to Long Island’s higher cost of living.

Below is an illustrative overview of typical annual salary ranges in Brookhaven, NY, based on common occupations and regional data trends:

Occupation Category (Brookhaven, NY) Typical Salary Range (Annual)
Healthcare Professionals (RNs, Specialists) $80,000 – $140,000
Education (Teachers, School Staff) $55,000 – $95,000
Skilled Trades (Electricians, Plumbers, HVAC) $60,000 – $110,000
Corporate & Professional Services $65,000 – $130,000
Retail & Service Positions $35,000 – $60,000

Overall, many full-time workers in Brookhaven see household incomes in the $80,000–$120,000 range, especially in dual-income households. However, prospective residents should pair these figures with a careful review of local living expenses, as higher earnings are often offset by higher housing and tax costs on Long Island.

Cost Of Living In Brookhaven NY

The cost of living in Brookhaven, NY is notably higher than the national average, driven largely by housing, property taxes, and transportation expenses. Nevertheless, when compared to western Suffolk County and closer-in Long Island communities, Brookhaven can feel relatively more affordable.

The following chart offers a simplified comparison of cost categories in Brookhaven, NY versus a U.S. average baseline of 100:

Cost Category Brookhaven, NY Index U.S. Average Index
Housing 135 100
Groceries 115 100
Utilities 105 100
Transportation 120 100
Healthcare 110 100

Housing and property taxes are the most significant budget items for Brookhaven residents. Long Island’s well-known school systems and municipal services come with higher tax bills, which renters feel indirectly through higher rents and homeowners pay directly.

Groceries, dining, and entertainment also trend above the U.S. average, but residents benefit from diverse shopping options, from local markets to national retailers. Meanwhile, utility costs remain moderate compared with more urban parts of the New York metro area.

Average Home Values And Rents In Brookhaven NY

The Brookhaven, NY real estate market is competitive but somewhat more accessible than in western Suffolk and Nassau Counties. Buyers can find a variety of housing types, including single-family homes, townhouses, and rental communities, often with larger lots than those found closer to New York City.

The table below outlines typical price and rent ranges in Brookhaven, NY:

Housing Type (Brookhaven, NY) Typical Price / Rent Range
Single-Family Home – Entry Level $450,000 – $550,000
Single-Family Home – Mid-Range $550,000 – $750,000
Single-Family Home – Higher-End / Waterfront $750,000 – $1,200,000+
Two-Bedroom Apartment (Monthly Rent) $2,300 – $3,000
Three-Bedroom House Rental (Monthly Rent) $2,800 – $3,800

Property taxes in Brookhaven, NY can be substantial, so buyers should work closely with a local real estate professional to understand total monthly carrying costs, not just mortgage payments. Additionally, because Brookhaven encompasses many hamlets and villages, home values can vary significantly from one neighborhood to another, with coastal communities and areas near top-rated schools commanding higher prices.

Best Neighborhoods In Brookhaven NY

Brookhaven is geographically large and includes a mix of coastal villages, suburban subdivisions, and more rural areas. As you explore the best neighborhoods in Brookhaven, NY, consider how proximity to the water, school districts, and commuting routes affect both lifestyle and housing costs.

Neighborhood / Hamlet Key Features Typical Appeal
Bellport Village / Bellport Historic charm, village amenities, waterfront access, arts scene Ideal for those seeking a picturesque coastal village with walkable streets and higher-end homes
East Setauket / Setauket Strong schools, historic homes, proximity to Stony Brook University Popular among professionals and families valuing education and a classic Long Island feel
Port Jefferson Station (bordering Port Jefferson) Access to Port Jefferson Village, ferry, dining, and shopping Attractive for commuters and those who want a vibrant harbor area nearby
Patchogue Revitalized downtown, waterfront dining, nightlife, and arts events Perfect for young professionals, creatives, and anyone seeking a lively social scene
Medford / Farmingville Suburban developments, more moderate pricing, highway access Works well for commuters needing quick access to major roadways and more budget-conscious housing

Choosing the right Brookhaven, NY neighborhood depends heavily on your commuting needs, lifestyle priorities, and budget. Coastal communities and historic villages tend to carry premium price tags, while more inland or rural hamlets may offer larger properties at comparatively lower prices.

Schools And Education In Brookhaven NY

For many families, the quality of schools in Brookhaven, NY is a top consideration. Brookhaven spans several well-regarded school districts, and this strong educational reputation is one reason property taxes and housing costs are higher than in many other parts of the country.

The table below highlights a few prominent school districts that serve portions of Brookhaven, NY:

School District Areas Served (Within/Adjacent To Brookhaven) Notable Characteristics
Three Village Central School District East Setauket, Setauket, Stony Brook area Known for strong academics, advanced coursework, and robust extracurricular offerings
Patchogue-Medford Union Free School District Patchogue, Medford and surrounding hamlets Offers diverse programs, arts and athletics; benefits from revitalized community engagement
South Country Central School District Bellport, North Bellport area Anchored by Bellport High School; supports a range of academic and arts initiatives
Longwood Central School District Parts of Coram, Ridge, and surrounding communities One of the largest districts in the region with comprehensive academic and athletic programs

In addition to public schools, Brookhaven, NY offers access to private and parochial schools, as well as nearby higher education institutions such as Stony Brook University and Suffolk County Community College. Collectively, these educational options further enhance the area’s appeal, particularly for families prioritizing long-term academic pathways.

Living In Brookhaven NY Final Thoughts

Evaluating a move to Brookhaven, NY means carefully balancing earnings potential, cost of living, and quality of life. While salaries in Brookhaven, NY are generally higher than the national average, residents also contend with elevated housing prices, significant property taxes, and above-average everyday expenses. However, in return, they enjoy robust school systems, coastal and village lifestyles, and a wide range of neighborhoods to fit different budgets and preferences.

For those who value access to Long Island’s beaches, a strong educational environment, and suburban space while remaining within reach of New York City, Brookhaven, NY offers a compelling blend of opportunity and lifestyle. By taking a close look at average salaries, housing markets, and neighborhood options, prospective residents can make a well-informed decision and find a community within Brookhaven that aligns with both their financial goals and their ideal way of living.

Frequently Asked Questions About Living in Brookhaven, NY

What is it like to live in Brookhaven, NY?

Living in Brookhaven, NY offers a balance of suburban comfort and coastal charm. As one of the largest towns on Long Island, it includes a variety of hamlets and villages, each with its own character, from quiet residential neighborhoods to busy commercial areas. Residents enjoy access to beaches along the Long Island Sound and the Atlantic Ocean, numerous parks, marinas, and nature preserves. The town provides a mix of single-family homes, rental options, and some newer developments, appealing to families, professionals, and retirees. While a car is usually necessary, public transportation options connect Brookhaven to other parts of Long Island and New York City, making it a practical choice for those who commute or travel frequently.

How is the cost of living in Brookhaven compared to other areas on Long Island?

The cost of living in Brookhaven is generally moderate compared to some of the more affluent western parts of Long Island, such as areas in Nassau County or closer to New York City. Housing prices and property taxes can still be significant, as is typical for Long Island, but there is a fairly wide range of pricing depending on the neighborhood, school district, and proximity to the water. Everyday expenses like groceries, utilities, and transportation are in line with regional averages. Many residents find that Brookhaven provides relatively better value in terms of space, access to amenities, and quality of life when compared with more densely populated or higher-priced Long Island communities.

What are the schools and educational opportunities like in Brookhaven?

Brookhaven is served by multiple public school districts, and educational quality can vary depending on the specific district and neighborhood. Many areas offer well-regarded elementary, middle, and high schools, along with extracurricular programs and special education services. In addition to public schools, families have access to private and parochial schools in and around the town. Brookhaven is also close to higher education institutions, including Stony Brook University and Suffolk County Community College, which provide opportunities for undergraduate, graduate, and continuing education. Prospective residents are encouraged to research individual school districts, review performance data, and visit schools to determine the best fit for their needs.

What transportation options and commute times can residents expect?

Most residents of Brookhaven rely on cars for daily transportation, as neighborhoods and amenities are spread out across a large geographic area. Major roadways such as the Long Island Expressway and Sunrise Highway provide access to other parts of Long Island and New York City, though traffic can be heavy during peak hours. Several Long Island Rail Road stations are located within or near Brookhaven, offering commuter rail service to Manhattan and other destinations, which can be convenient for those working in the city. Local bus routes operated by Suffolk County Transit serve some communities, but service levels may not be sufficient as a sole transportation option for many residents. Commute times vary widely depending on the starting point, destination, and time of day.

What recreational activities and community amenities are available in Brookhaven?

Brookhaven offers a wide range of recreational activities and community amenities. Residents have access to town beaches, marinas, boat ramps, and nature preserves, providing opportunities for swimming, boating, fishing, and hiking. Local parks feature playgrounds, sports fields, walking trails, and picnic areas. The town operates recreation programs for all ages, including youth sports, senior activities, and seasonal events. Cultural and historic sites, such as museums and landmarks, highlight the area’s maritime and colonial heritage. Shopping centers, restaurants, and local businesses are spread throughout the town, and nearby villages provide additional dining and entertainment options. These amenities contribute to a strong sense of community and a high quality of life for those living in Brookhaven.

editor's pick

latest video

Mail Icon

news via inbox

Sign up to get local tips delivered to your inbox.

you might also like